How to Make It
Place the two pieces of foam board together and draw a giant circle with a pencil, aiming to put one half of the bagel on each sheet of foam board. Then draw a smaller circle in the middle. Using a box cutter or X-Acto knife, cut out the two halves of your bagel. Attach with hot glue, and reinforce with tape on one side, if necessary.
Prepare the bagel shape as you did with the everything bagel, including tracing, cutting, and painting. The biggest difference is that you will not be adding everything seasoning on the top or cream cheese on the back.